Which Eldritch Horror Expansion Should You Play First?
Once you've faced the Ancient Ones in the Eldritch Horror core set, the next big question is which expansion to pick up first. Each one adds new investigators, Ancient Ones, encounters, and mechanics, but they vary in scope, price, and how they change the game. The good news is that all of them require the core set to play, so you're starting from a solid base.
Below we break down the four main expansions by what they actually deliver, so you can match your choice to your group's appetite for complexity, theme, and new content.
At a Glance: What Each Expansion Adds
- Eldritch Horror: Forsaken Lore: Forsaken Lore thrusts investigators into perilous new encounters, with new Research cards and Ancient Ones defeated in the past attempting to reclaim the world. It's the smallest and most affordable expansion, focusing on deepening the existing game rather than adding a side board or campaign mode.

Eldritch Horror: Forsaken Lore - Eldritch Horror: Masks of Nyarlathotep: Masks of Nyarlathotep introduces Personal Stories for each investigator and a Campaign mode, plus new Adventures and Mystic Ruins. This expansion adds narrative depth and replayability through character-specific stories and a linked campaign, ideal for groups who enjoy ongoing stories.

Eldritch Horror: Masks of Nyarlathotep - Eldritch Horror: The Dreamlands: The Dreamlands introduces an entirely new side board portraying the mystical Dreamlands, plus two new Ancient Ones: Altach-Nacha and Hypnos. If your group wants a physical new area to explore with its own encounters and rules, this expansion delivers a big change in scope and atmosphere.
- Eldritch Horror: The Mountains of Madness: Mountains of Madness includes a side board of Antarctica, eight investigators, two Ancient Ones, and new Adventure and Prelude cards. It offers a large amount of content with a focused Antarctic theme, plus new card types that shape the global struggle.
How They Compare: Scope, Theme, and Price
The four expansions fall into two broad categories: those that expand the core game without a new board (Forsaken Lore, Masks of Nyarlathotep) and those that add a side board (The Dreamlands, Mountains of Madness). The side-board expansions are pricier and add more physical components, while the others focus on cards and new rules.
- Forsaken Lore: Priced at $23.42 (compare at $32.99), it's the budget-friendly choice. It adds new encounters, Research cards, and Ancient Ones but no side board or campaign. Best for players who want more variety without changing the core flow.
- Masks of Nyarlathotep: At $38.99 (compare at $64.99), it introduces Personal Stories and a Campaign mode, adding narrative stakes. No side board, but the new Adventures and Mystic Ruins enrich the existing locations.
- The Dreamlands: Priced at $41.59 (compare at $64.99), it adds a side board for dream-world exploration, eight new investigators, and two Ancient Ones. Great for groups that want a distinct new realm to explore.
- Mountains of Madness: At $44.84 (compare at $64.99), it includes an Antarctic side board, eight investigators, two Ancient Ones, and Prelude cards. The largest and most expensive, it suits players who want a complete new theater of play.
Which One Should You Choose First?
If you're on a budget or just want more variety without changing the game's structure, start with Forsaken Lore. It's the cheapest way to add meaningful content.
If your group loves narrative and character development, Masks of Nyarlathotep's Personal Stories and Campaign mode offer the most story-driven experience without a side board.
If you're ready for a bigger change and want to explore a completely new setting, The Dreamlands or Mountains of Madness are both excellent. The Dreamlands leans into surreal fantasy, while Mountains of Madness brings a cold, Lovecraftian horror. Choose based on which theme appeals more.
All expansions require the Eldritch Horror Core Set, and none are standalone. Whichever you pick, you'll get new investigators, Ancient Ones, and encounters that keep the global conspiracy fresh.





